
Commodore Perry Estate
Best for travelers who want a refined, full-service estate with on-site dining, a spa partner (ELEMIS), and event spaces.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Commodore Perry Estate is a five-star, full-service estate and restored 1928 mansion with on-site dining, a spa suite, and a garden pool—best for travelers who want a polished, amenity-rich Austin stay. Single Malt Manor Downtown Austin is a 3-star, downtown rental-style vacation home (Superior House, 5 Bedrooms) near Sixth Street—best for groups who want a private house within walking distance of central Austin nightlife.
Updated · about 2.0 miles apart

Best for travelers who want a refined, full-service estate with on-site dining, a spa partner (ELEMIS), and event spaces.

Best for groups seeking a private 5-bedroom house in Central East Austin within easy walking distance of Sixth Street and UT Austin.
When Commodore Perry Estate wins: Choose Commodore Perry Estate if you want a full-service luxury experience—onsite signature dining (Lutie's), an intimate spa (The Spa Suite with ELEMIS treatments), a staffed front desk and concierge, formal event space, and a secluded garden pool. It’s the better pick for couples, families, or anyone wanting resort amenities and service.
When Single Malt Manor Downtown Austin wins: Pick Single Malt Manor if your priority is a standalone house in downtown Austin for a group or family who values proximity to Sixth Street, live music, and central attractions. The property offers a private 5-bedroom house with an outdoor pool and basic conveniences like washer/dryer and complimentary Wi‑Fi.
Bottom line: Commodore Perry Estate is a service-forward, historic luxury estate with restaurants, a spa, and organized programming; Single Malt Manor Downtown Austin is a practical downtown vacation home option for groups who want private space and immediate access to Austin’s central nightlife and sights.
| Category | Commodore Perry Estate | Single Malt Manor Downtown Austin |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Refined, historic estate with polished service and curated wellness programming | Rental-style downtown house geared to groups wanting central access |
| Location | Hyde Park/Hancock, about 2 miles north of downtown Austin (4100 Red River St) | Central East Austin / Downtown (1004 E 7th St), a few minutes' walk to Sixth Street |
| Size & rooms | 54 rooms and suites across the restored mansion and grounds | Superior House, 5 Bedrooms (single vacation home) |
| Star rating | 5-star (Auberge Resorts Collection) | 3-star |
| Pools | One garden-framed outdoor pool available to guests (seasonal poolside service) | Number of outdoor pools - 1 (private to the house) |
| Restaurants & bars | Lutie's (signature garden-to-table), The Mansion (guest dining) and Pool menu | Not published |
| Spa & wellness | The Spa Suite (ELEMIS partnership), 24-hour fitness center, weekly classes | Not published |
| Known for | Historic 1928 Italianate mansion, estate gardens, event and wedding venues | Walkable access to Sixth Street, UT Austin and downtown attractions |
| Parking & check-in | Valet/self parking (estate fee covers parking options); staffed front desk with 3:00 PM check-in | Limited onsite parking; no front desk—self check-in with access code (check-in begins 4:00 PM) |
| Accessibility & family policy | Family-friendly, wheelchair accessible features and accessible pool lift | Not wheelchair accessible; minimum age to book/check-in policies vary (check supplier rules) |
Commodore Perry Estate sits on 10 landscaped acres in Hyde Park, roughly two miles north of downtown Austin.
Better for guests who want quiet gardens and easy car access to cultural sites north of downtown.
Single Malt Manor is in Central East Austin just off E 7th St, within easy walking distance of Sixth Street and many downtown attractions.
Better for travelers who want to be in the middle of downtown nightlife and walking distance to central sights.
Commodore Perry Estate offers 54 individually styled rooms and suites within a restored mansion and grounds.
More variety and service in a hotel setting, including 24-hour front desk support.
Single Malt Manor is listed as a single vacation home: Superior House, 5 Bedrooms, Non Smoking, Private Pool.
A single private house rather than a selection of serviced rooms—good for groups wanting a home base in downtown Austin.
Commodore Perry Estate is a culinary-focused property with multiple dining venues.
Better for travelers who want on-site, reservation-style dining and a variety of restaurant settings.
The supplier listing for Single Malt Manor does not publish on-site restaurants or bars.
Expect to eat out in downtown Austin rather than rely on on-site dining.
Commodore Perry Estate offers a garden-framed outdoor pool as part of its estate amenities.
Pool access is integrated with the estate experience and service offerings.
Single Malt Manor includes one outdoor pool listed in the supplier information.
Good for private pool downtime, but without hotel pool services or poolside dining.
Commodore Perry Estate provides a spa partnership, fitness center and organized wellness programming.
Better for travelers seeking onsite wellness services and quiet evening programming.
Single Malt Manor's supplier listing highlights its downtown position for nightlife rather than onsite wellness services.
Better for guests who prioritize being close to Austin’s downtown nightlife and live music.

Commodore Perry Estate — multiple estate restaurants, room service, staffed front desk and concierge.

Single Malt Manor Downtown Austin — a 5-bedroom private house a short walk from Sixth Street and UT Austin.

Commodore Perry Estate — The Spa Suite (ELEMIS), 24-hour fitness center and scheduled wellness classes.

Single Malt Manor Downtown Austin — one Superior House with five bedrooms and private pool for group stays.
Commodore Perry Estate — it has Lutie's, Mansion dining, poolside service, and a 24-hour front desk/concierge.
Single Malt Manor Downtown Austin — its Central East Austin location is within walking distance of Sixth Street and downtown venues.
Not published — the supplier listing does not show an on-site spa. Commodore Perry Estate does publish a spa partnership with ELEMIS.
Yes. Commodore Perry Estate welcomes guests of all ages when accompanied by an adult; a guest must be 21+ to book a room.
Explore how Commodore Perry Estate stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·