
Commodore Perry Estate
Best for travelers who want a small, gardened estate with historic character and estate-centered dining and events.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Commodore Perry Estate is a reimagined 1928 Italianate mansion and garden estate just north of downtown Austin; read this if you want a small, garden-forward luxury stay with estate dining and private-feeling grounds. Austin Proper Hotel is a design-forward five-star luxury hotel in central Austin; read this if you prefer a modern, downtown base with more rooms, multiple restaurants, and active urban access.
Updated · about 2 miles (3.2 km) apart

Best for travelers who want a small, gardened estate with historic character and estate-centered dining and events.

Best for travelers who want modern, design-driven luxury in the heart of downtown with multiple dining options and event space.
When Commodore Perry Estate wins: choose Commodore Perry when you want a quieter, smaller-property experience with garden surroundings, a single secluded pool, intimate Mansion dining and wedding/event spaces on historic grounds.
When Austin Proper Hotel wins: choose Austin Proper when you want to be in downtown Austin for nightlife, concerts and business, prefer a larger hotel with multiple restaurants/bars, a full-service spa and more meeting space, or need more room-type variety.
Bottom line: both are five-star Austin choices but they serve different needs — Commodore Perry for an estate-style, intimate getaway and events; Austin Proper for central, design-forward urban luxury and larger-group or conference stays.
| Category | Commodore Perry Estate | Austin Proper Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, historic Italianate mansion estate with garden-focused public spaces | Design-forward, modern five-star hotel in downtown Austin |
| Location | Hyde Park / Hancock, about 2 miles north of downtown Austin | Downtown Austin (West 2nd Street), steps from Lady Bird Lake and Sixth Street |
| Size (rooms) | 54 rooms and suites | 244 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Year / building | Main mansion built 1928; reopened/renovated in 2020 | Not published |
| Pools | One outdoor garden-framed pool (available to guests all day; nightly maintenance after 8 p.m.) | One outdoor pool with cabanas (cabanas surcharge) |
| Restaurants & bars | Lutie's (garden-to-table), Mansion dining (guest-only), Pool menu; reservations required for Lutie's | Three restaurants and three bars/lounges, including Peacock (Mediterranean); room service 24-hour |
| Spa & wellness | The Spa Suite (Elemis partnership) plus weekly fitness classes and 24-hour fitness center | Full-service spa with massages and body treatments, 24-hour fitness and on-site fitness classes (Pilates, yoga) |
| Events & meeting space | Multiple estate venues (Sunken Garden, Chapel, Mansion) for 12–200 guests and more than 15,000 sq ft of event space | Conference space ~14,000 sq ft and 2 meeting rooms; ballroom and banquet facilities |
| Family & pets | Family-friendly (children welcome when accompanied by adult); pet-friendly (pet fee $125 per dog, up to two) | Adults allowed; pets allowed with a pet fee (supplier lists pet fee as USD 100 per pet, per stay) |
| Airport distance | About 9 miles / roughly 20 minutes to Austin-Bergstrom Intl. Airport (AUS) | About 16.1 miles (26 km) to Austin-Bergstrom Intl. Airport (AUS) per supplier listing |
Commodore Perry Estate sits on 10 landscaped acres in the Hyde Park/Hancock neighborhood about two miles north of downtown.
Better if you want a quieter, residential setting and quick drives to cultural sites rather than walking access to downtown venues.
Austin Proper is in central downtown Austin near Lady Bird Lake, Sixth Street and the Moody Theater.
Better if you want to be in the center of downtown with walkable access to entertainment and city sights.
Commodore Perry has 54 rooms and suites housed in a restored mansion with historic details.
Better for travelers who value historic architecture, fewer rooms and a quieter room inventory.
Austin Proper offers 244 individually decorated guestrooms across many room categories.
Better for travelers who want more room-type options and flexible configurations in a larger hotel.
Commodore Perry centers dining around Lutie's garden-to-table concept plus Mansion dining for guests and members.
Better if you want farm-to-table and estate-grown ingredients in a small set of curated venues.
Austin Proper features several in-house restaurants and bars and 24-hour room service.
Better if you want multiple dining choices without leaving the hotel and a lively in-hotel bar scene.
Commodore Perry’s single outdoor pool is set within the estate gardens and is available to guests throughout the day.
Better if you prefer a single, secluded pool experience framed by gardens rather than an urban pool crowd.
Austin Proper offers an outdoor pool with pool cabanas available for surcharge.
Better if you want a downtown pool experience and the option to reserve cabanas (for a surcharge).
Commodore Perry emphasizes curated wellness programming and smaller spa facilities.
Better for guests who want a programmed, small-scale wellness focus within a quieter property.
Austin Proper combines a full-service spa and 24-hour fitness with downtown nightlife on the doorstep.
Better if you want a full spa plus immediate access to downtown nightlife and cultural programming.

Commodore Perry Estate — multiple historic venues and outdoor gardens with event capacities up to ~200 guests.

Austin Proper — walkable to Sixth Street, Lady Bird Lake and downtown venues.

Austin Proper — larger, design-led property with several restaurants and bars.

Commodore Perry Estate — smaller property with garden dining, a secluded pool and historic mansion rooms.
Commodore Perry Estate — it’s a small mansion estate on landscaped grounds with garden dining and a secluded pool.
Austin Proper — it’s in central downtown, a short walk to Moody Theater, Sixth Street and Lady Bird Lake.
Both welcome adults and children. Commodore Perry is explicitly family-friendly and pet-friendly (pet fee noted); Austin Proper allows pets subject to its pet fee.
Yes. Commodore Perry has The Spa Suite (Elemis partnership) and a 24-hour fitness center; Austin Proper has a full-service spa and 24-hour fitness with on-site classes.
Explore how Commodore Perry Estate stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·