
Commodore Perry Estate
Best for travelers who want a small, historic estate with garden dining and a secluded outdoor pool.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Commodore Perry Estate is a restored 1928 Italianate mansion and garden estate north of downtown Austin that suits travelers looking for a quiet, historic luxury stay with on-site dining and gardens. 1 Hotel Austin is a lifestyle-oriented, sustainability-focused upscale hotel in downtown Austin’s Rainey District for guests who want modern design, a rooftop pool, and brand-driven wellness offerings.
Updated · about 2.2 miles apart

Best for travelers who want a small, historic estate with garden dining and a secluded outdoor pool.

Best for travelers who prefer a contemporary, sustainability-focused lifestyle hotel with a rooftop pool and a larger set of room types and suites.
When Commodore Perry Estate wins: choose the Estate if you want a small, quiet property with historic character, garden dining at Lutie's, intimate spa treatments (The Spa Suite with ELEMIS), and priority access to Mansion dining and private-event spaces.
When 1 Hotel Austin wins: pick 1 Hotel if you prefer a modern, eco-minded brand experience in the Rainey District with many room configurations, a rooftop pool, a larger spa program (Bamford Wellness Spa), and the conveniences of a downtown tower.
Bottom line: both are upscale options in Austin but serve different styles—Commodore Perry for a boutique, estate stay focused on gardens and history; 1 Hotel Austin for a contemporary, sustainability-driven downtown experience with more rooms and urban amenities.
| Category | Commodore Perry Estate | 1 Hotel Austin |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Restored 1928 Italianate mansion on landscaped grounds; intimate, estate feel | Contemporary lifestyle luxury tower with biophilic design and eco-focus |
| Location | Hyde Park / Hancock neighborhood, about 2 miles north of downtown | Downtown Rainey District, in the Waterline tower |
| Size | 54 rooms and suites | 252 guest rooms and 60 suites |
| Star rating | 5-star (Auberge Resorts Collection) | 4-star |
| Pools | One garden-framed outdoor pool, available to guests all day | Rooftop pool (guest access noted in supplier listing) |
| Restaurants & bars | Lutie's (garden-to-table), Mansion dining (guest- and member-only), poolside menu | Sustainable fine-dining restaurant and additional food & beverage outlets (supplier listing) |
| Spa & wellness | The Spa Suite in partnership with ELEMIS; weekly fitness classes and 24-hour gym | Bamford Wellness Spa and brand-driven wellness programming |
| Known for | Historic mansion, gardens, wedding and event spaces | Biophilic design, sustainability focus, large downtown presence |
| Pet policy | Pet-friendly; pet fee listed (example: $125 per dog on fact sheet) | Small pets allowed (under 5 kg) per supplier listing |
| Accessibility & family policy | Family-friendly; guests of all ages welcome when accompanied by an adult | Not adults-only; family policy not published in supplier listing |
Commodore Perry Estate sits on 10 landscaped acres in the Hyde Park/Hancock area, north of downtown Austin.
Choose Commodore Perry for a quieter, garden-focused location with easy drive access to downtown sites.
1 Hotel Austin occupies floors within the Waterline tower in the Rainey District, a downtown neighborhood of bars and restaurants.
Choose 1 Hotel when you prefer being in a central, walkable downtown neighborhood with rooftop views.
Commodore Perry offers 54 rooms and suites blending historic architecture with modern comforts.
Pick the Estate for fewer, characterful rooms with historic touches and garden-facing options.
1 Hotel Austin offers a broad range of room types and suite configurations tailored to lifestyle travelers.
Choose 1 Hotel if you want many room options and modern, nature-inspired design elements.
Commodore Perry centers dining around Lutie's garden-to-table concept and Mansion dining for guests and members.
If garden-focused, seasonal menus and a small estate dining program matter, Commodore Perry is a strong fit.
1 Hotel Austin highlights a sustainable fine-dining restaurant alongside other F&B outlets consistent with the brand.
Pick 1 Hotel if you want a brand-led dining program with sustainability emphasis and varied outlets.
The Estate has one garden-framed outdoor swimming pool available to guests throughout the day.
Commodore Perry’s pool is quieter and integrated with gardens—better for relaxed pool time and family use.
1 Hotel Austin features a rooftop pool as one of its headline amenities.
Choose 1 Hotel for a rooftop pool experience and city views; expect a busier, urban pool scene.
Commodore Perry emphasizes intimate spa treatments and regular wellness classes under Auberge’s programming.
Commodore Perry suits guests seeking boutique spa treatments and scheduled wellness programming in a calm setting.
1 Hotel Austin lists the Bamford Wellness Spa and brand wellness programming in its supplier highlights.
Pick 1 Hotel for a branded wellness program and on-site spa in a downtown, design-forward setting.

Commodore Perry Estate — restored 1928 mansion, gardens, small number of rooms and estate dining.

1 Hotel Austin — brand-forward sustainability, biophilic design and a rooftop pool in downtown Rainey District.

Commodore Perry Estate — family-friendly programming, lawn games, and a garden pool accessible to all ages.

1 Hotel Austin — many room types (including panoramic and balcony suites) across 252 rooms and 60 suites.
Commodore Perry Estate—its 10 acres, gardens and a secluded outdoor pool suit guests wanting a quieter, historic environment.
1 Hotel Austin—located in the Rainey District downtown tower, it’s closer to bars, restaurants, and central Austin attractions.
Yes. Commodore Perry is explicitly family-friendly with children welcome; 1 Hotel Austin’s supplier listing does not indicate an adults-only policy.
Commodore Perry’s Spa Suite partners with ELEMIS for intimate treatments; 1 Hotel Austin lists the Bamford Wellness Spa—both offer spa services, but scale and treatment menus should be confirmed with each property.
Explore how Commodore Perry Estate stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·